33 Comments
User's avatar
Lance Smith's avatar

Likely Yascha is more focused on the ideological persuasion of the recent upstart parties in Europe and sees something similar happening here. It’s possible of course but I’d argue the difference is that so many people are disillusioned by both D and R because both parties have raced to their respective spectrum edges. These parties used to be center-left and center-right but clearly neither calls the center home anymore. This is particularly an issue for the Democrats - in their wholesale embrace of divisive, left-wing “Progressive” ideology and their potential embrace of socialism/communism [which will all but guarantee I’ll never vote for another Democrat again] - and it is quickly becoming an issue for Republicans as the New Right takes hold online. This has opened a gulf between them that has never existed in the past in which neither party cleaves to the center and the Venn diagram which used to describe our duopoly continues to separate.

Personally I’d love to see a truly centrist, business forward, civil libertarian, liberal-nationalist third party arise to combat the authoritarianism, doomerism, and divisivism of our parties. It would put both major parties on notice and keep them both honest. Or it would continue to push them to their respective extremes at which point one would likely finally die leading to our future duopoly.

Because while I too have little trouble picking between these two parties given the options put forth by the other party (though I’m guessing you and I pick different defaults), I don’t pick out of love or loyalty.

Duncan Ritchie's avatar

The problem with duopolies is that they become entrenched and complacent—and sometimes corrupt. In the US, the duopoly has established structural impediments to prevent the rise of challengers. Who would want to share the prize?

That’s left a significant number of Americans without a political home. In 2023, Pew reported that 3 in 10 Americans were dissatisfied with both the Democratic and Republican parties. By 2025, as you note, the Gallup poll found that a new high of 45% of American adults identified as political independents versus only 27% each for Democrats and Republicans. Perhaps more strikingly, that same Gallup poll found a majority of Gen Z and Millennials identified as independents.

Those independents are left to choose between two bad options. Other elements of the system compound the problem—the American primary system, for example, actively promotes extremist candidates whose bombastic, performative brand of politics can be off-putting to unaligned voters.

The question is: will reform come before revolution?

Sara Sharick's avatar

Here is my general election voting strategy for the foreseeable future: vote for anyone other than the R or D, even if I have to write someone in. I think every disaffected voter should do this, and it doesn’t even matter if we don’t all pick the same person. The result is that the total vote denominator stays the same (or goes up since so many already don’t vote) and *drives down* the numerators of the eventual winner. Even if an R or D wins the plurality, if that plurality reads as 30% instead of 48 or 52%, that will send a highly visible message that people aren’t happy. A “win” of 52% with a 50% turnout still looks reasonable on paper. I want something that looks terrible on paper even if it is still a win for them. They can’t ignore it. They’ll try. And they’ll absolutely take a 52% win with 50% turnout as a mandate. I want to take that from them even if I don’t have anyone I actually like to vote for. But it takes a critical mass of people doing the same.

Nancy Merbitz's avatar

So you’re willing to risk more years of Republican rule? Sheesh. More of this. Are you actually reading about what he and they are doing to the structure of the country: the infrastructure, the protections on natural areas and water and air, the legal protections, any semblance of freedom of speech? How long do you think you and your ideas whatever they are will survive the next 2 4 8 years? Like elections? Kiss em goodbye. Vote Dem and then take over that party. Go full on Socialist for all I care. Just don’t enable more of what’s happening now FFS

Sara Sharick's avatar

Democrats take all their votes as a mandate while ignoring how many people hate large portions of their platform. “We’re not republicans” isn’t good enough anymore.

Pamela Smith's avatar

Well we aren’t going to have a Republic if the Dems don’t take control of Congress and shut this fascist down. You might reconsider possibly the last vote of your lifetime.

Sara Sharick's avatar

First of all, that’s overblown, second, democrats have plenty of their own authoritarian tendencies, and third, nothing about this strategy assumes republicans win that plurality. There are plenty of both disaffected republicans and democrats, and I don’t think I said which one I am.

Ray Andrews's avatar

Trump will be history in two years. Next Rep candidate will be Rubio or Vance. Both very intelligent men who might just possibly have some concern for their country. For the time being they have to lick Trump's ass of course, but that's politics.

Ray Andrews's avatar

> that will send a highly visible message that people aren’t happy

But do they give a damn about the people? All that matters to them is that they win the current cycle. Come to that, one might say, particularly among the Rats, they don't even care about winning, they care about rising thru the ranks of the party itself by performing their woke virtue even if it costs them the election. Why else would the Rats keep doubling down on policies that they know perfectly well are rejected by the voters?

Sara Sharick's avatar

Perhaps. But what then is the option? This seems defeatist and I’m not there yet.

Ray Andrews's avatar

Tricky problem isn't it? Short term, it would seem to me that job one is trying to reduce the damage that Trump is doing, yet the Rats are doubling down on wokeness which is not just a political threat, but an arrow aimed at the heart of Western civilization. And, as you say, if you vote for either one, you are perpetuating the same old rotten establishment. No easy answer.

Nancy Merbitz's avatar

Doubling down on wokeness? Heart of “western civilization”? So people trying to leave areas destabilized by ravages of climate change are our greatest threat?

Louise Meymand's avatar

MAGA, although under Republican umbrella, is more of a true third party supported by the majority. Many MAGA members do not like the old Republican platform. Most MAGA do represent common sense, moderate beliefs. The 1980s moderate beliefs, not the current liberal shifted moderate beliefs.

Gabriel Conroy's avatar

I think a more likely scenario is that another party will emerge to replace one of the existing parties. Such a change would also alter the old party. I'd say it'd be similar in form to how the original Republican Party, though the animating issue would be different and it likely wouldn't be along similarly stark sectional lines.

There'd be a reversion to some sort of duopoly mean at any rate. A "third-party success" wouldn't inaugurate a system where three parties (or more) regularly compete with significant hope of victory. It would quickly become a new two-party system.

Rich Owen's avatar

The reality is that in the US, a major party hostile take over is much more effective than a third party campaign. As Mr. Mounk hinted at, the existing duopoly has enacted structural ballot access barriers. These include previous ballot access, petition requirements, and at times very onerous voter signature requirements including being geographically distributed (eg, a certain number in each polling district) and even the pen's ink color.

For example, in 2024 presidential, the Libertarian party was on the ballot in 48 (of 51 including DC) jurisdictions, the Green party was on 39, the Party for Socialism and Liberation was on 19, and so on. Down ballot offices are even more restricted.

Let's not forget that Congress also has structural barriers to a third party. To be on committees, office holders must caucus with one of the two parties. This can be withdrawn if the office holder is not sufficiently "loyal" to their selected party. Without committee assignments, a third party office holder is unlikely to bring home enough bacon to get re-elected. Changing this would require a new third party majority, and that just isn't possible with the ballot restrictions.

While Trump has shown us that a hostile takeover of a party can be "successful" and can include lower offices, I wonder whether this model has lasting power. Will this model survive the end of his term and his attempts to anoint a successor? Or will the MAGA takeover fracture and end up as just another AOL-like disaster?

Jim Crist's avatar

Both parties have been captured by big money in politics and don't represent the working class. We need a grassroots movement to reform our election system. Better election systems already exist. Check out this article... https://www.washingtonpost.com/ripple/2026/07/31/americans-hate-the-two-party-system/

Steven Curtis's avatar

But the two party system is not working for the people. Both parties have resorted to negative ads and vote buying to "win". No benefit from either side winning is evident. Both advocate more spending and larger debt. So, it has become a power struggle of donor and lobbying efforts to pick which oligarchs rule. We need as many other choices as we can get so as many parties as we can get. If we took money out if campaigns or found honest adult leaders on the side of the people maybe two parties could work. Mow, we desperately need to oust incumbents and replace them with citizens who will favor the freedom of the people (instead of taking their money and giving a small portion back. If it is a good idea, but it doesn't work, it is not a good idea. These two parties are not a good idea for America or for liberty.

David W. Zoll's avatar

Don’t forget John Anderson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_B._Anderson

He illustrates what I think is most likely to happen. The R’s go too far right and the D’s go too far left, opening up the middle for a uniting candidate or movement. But it is a very very difficult path to success with each state representing a barrier to entry.

The US system has serious structural differences from other countries that makes the formation and success of a third party very difficult.

Steven Curtis's avatar

But difficult is not impossible. When did Americans become afraid of actions just because they are difficult.

David W. Zoll's avatar

The ideal scenario would be a new centrist party that embraced a set of values which almost all American voters could agree with and would endorse.

Nancy Merbitz's avatar

So, what are the cultural issues you are moderate on? And what do you think of Netanyahu?

Tubthumping's avatar

US President is NOT directly elected. The French president is.

This is why candidates win the EC vote w/o wimming the popular vote.