217 Comments
User's avatar
MHYDE's avatar

I got into pointless arguments online after Brian Thompson was murdered and so many were quick to celebrate because they viewed it as just. Just making the basic argument, “we don’t settle policy differences with violence in this society, and if that became routine, it wouldn’t be a society any of us would want to live in.” But so many pushed back and argued that, essentially, it’s ok to kill as long as you feel strongly enough about something, and it doesn’t hurt if you’re also photogenic like Saint Luigi (this argument could defend abortion clinic shootings as well, but it’s gauche to notice that). This is where that leads. Is this what anyone wants?

Nathan Ladd's avatar

The moderate left pays way too much attention to the extreme right, and the moderate right pays way too much attention to the extreme left. If moderate Americans of either stripe don't wise up to this dynamic, and how it distorts our perception of where our society's dangers lie, we will cede our political system to destructive extremists. We could lose it all.

melanin's avatar

Kind of hard to buy this when it was the moderate/mainstream right that have stood behind the January 6 coup attempt and still can't safely say out loud that Joe Biden won the 2020 election. Charlie Kirk himself was "moderate" right and supported raising monry to bail out the man who attacked Nancy Pelosi's husband. The "moderate left" mostly pays attention to the actual leaders and highly influential insiders of the Republican Party who run the country, and it's a worrying picture.

Wayne Savage's avatar

It's simply not true that the moderate right stood behind the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol. Such an assertion is itself inflammatory.

Zorost's avatar

J6 was too little, too late. And Biden did steal the 2020 election. Explain the 15+ million votes that appeared for him, that didn't exist during any other election, or the actions of the many Leftist poll workers to hide their actions.

Your nonsense shows that we aren't on the same team any more. Debating who is at fault is no longer relevant, it is Us versus Them.

Eric73's avatar

Explain where Biden's "extra votes" came from? I assume you're talking about the 16 million over what Hillary got? And you think that means he stole them? Are you serious?

Donald Trump himself got 12 million more votes than he did in 2016. I guess that means he stole them too?

We had 330 million people in this country in 2020. Probably around 250 million of voting age. And 155 million of them voted for Biden and Trump combined. That still leaves almost 100 million who didn't vote.

There's your explanation for where Biden's 16 million extra votes came from. From the roughly 125 million people who didn't vote in 2016—almost half rhe electorate—28 million of them decided they didn't want to sit this one out because they either really hated or really liked Trump.

And the hate-to-like ratio was about 4:3.

This isn't rocket science. It's simple math, and you could have easily figured this out if you'd just checked the numbers.

But you read some little snippet somewhere posted by some conspiracy theorist and abandoned your critical thinking capacity, because you apparently wanted a reason to hate your fellow Americans.

We can't survive when people like you aren't even trying.

Zorost's avatar

You don't understand the argument. Total votes for both parties is usually roughly the same, some in the middle go back and forth. Super popular people like Obama increased the total by a bit, but not nearly as much as Biden did. Biden couldn't fill a small town high school auditorium for his "rallies" yet somehow hordes of people decide to vote in 2020. If they hated Trump so much, where were they in 2024?

You completely ignore all the video evidence of Leftist poll workers breaking laws to create votes out of thin air.

We aren't the same people, the same nation. We just happen to share a citizenship created by paperwork. The sooner we all split up, or you all disappear in smoke, the better.

Ken Kovar's avatar

Yes and what are you helmet boys doing for me LATELY as a certified white man..?? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r9uizdKZAGE

Zorost's avatar

What are you babbling about, boomer?

Ken Hehir's avatar

So very, very well said. The USA is a "middle of the road" country. 70% or more of us are "moderate" in our thinking... close to the middle even if on one side or the other. The extremes of the left and right are destroying our nation. In their minds it's "all or nothing". It's up to the 60 to 70% of us to stop cow-towing to the extremeists. It's time for the media to stop kneeling to them for the sake of clicks and views.

Filk's avatar

Thank you Yascha.

Heather Melton Fox's avatar

Indeed people in this country should not be murdered for political speech - or for going to the grocery store or school or church. Gun violence in this country in a singular sickness and one I hope we can find the humanity to confront. Mr. Kirk said he believed that deaths “every single year” from gun violence were the price we have to pay to have the second amendment to protect our “God-given rights.” I deeply disagreed with him on this and virtually everything he ever said. But there is nothing okay about the ease with which people can obtain and shoot guns at people for any number of indefensible reasons including to silence the speech of someone with whom you disagree. I will pray for his wife and young children as I do for all victims of gun violence in this country.

Odysseus's avatar

No matter how you feel about the relationship of this country with guns, it is too late to do anything about it. There are probably close to 500 million guns in civilian hands and are easy to build from scratch. I guess we will soon find out if Charlie’s thesis is correct. Will we stop and walk back from the abyss? I think so. Political violence doesn’t lead to civil war unless political leaders believe they can impose their will through force. This is a delusional position given the availability of arms in this country. I think the most likely scenario is the political violence in the U.S. and Western Europe in the 60s or at worst the Irish troubles.

Cora Greenberg's avatar

Agree 100%. Just one correction: the Dems in Congress did not object to the moment of silence, they objected to Representative Boebart's request for a spoken prayer after the moment of silence they all observed.

Alta Ifland's avatar

A good essay, but it falls on deaf years. Just read the comments here. We have entered a dark period and both sides have brought us here (and to answer one of the comments below, in this case and most recently, the violence definitely comes from the Left, but the Right did its part prior to that). Of course, right now, one would hope that all those great minds on the Left would stop pretending that this violence doesn't exist. Maybe if the media tried to go back to a non-partisan perspective, there would no longer be an "us" versus "them."

Brian Owendoff's avatar

Charlie Kirk didn’t storm buildings, loot stores, or burn cities—he just talked. And that’s what terrified them.

James Quinn's avatar

“it’s worth [the] cost of, unfortunately, some gun deaths every single year so that we can have the Second Amendment.” Charlie Kirk

As you sow, so shall you reap.

I’d further note that for the first time in our history, we have a president of the United States who has frequently and openly espoused violence in support of his agenda, who incited violence on his behalf and who then pardoned the violent because they had been violent on his behalf.

I do not in any way condone what happened to Charlie Kirk, or to anyone else along any part of our political spectrum, but when violence is espoused from the top, no one is safe.

Tildeb's avatar

Another "I don't condone, but..." apologist, I see. The 'but' indicates exactly the opposite of the claim that you say you don't condone. Your speech indicates otherwise.

James Quinn's avatar

You don’t read very carefully do you.

Tildeb's avatar

Actually, I do. Perhaps you could consider my point a little more seriously.

James Quinn's avatar

Actually you don’t. Being against violence has nothing to do with suggesting that its espousal by the President of United States doesn’t help and may indeed hinder efforts to end it.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Sep 11, 2025
Comment removed
James Quinn's avatar

So what do you think Mr. Kirk meant? Having the Second Amendment is worth a couple of gun deaths a year - as long as one of them isn’t mine.

Lightwing's avatar

He likely meant accidental killings due to ignorance about gun safety. This was not accidental, it was murder. And, it's likely that being called out on the spot and not having time to think his response through, he committed the sin of broadbrushing.

And, even if he did mean to include murder in that statement, you gloating over his death just shows how immature you are. You don't want the best for this country. You just want to be right. You want your "gotcha" moment. The man had a right to his opinion and didn't deserve to die for it.

We are all Americans, a nation of people with a variety of opinions. Learning to agree to disagree peacefully is one of the things that holds us together. If you and others like you continue to justify political violence, we are going to lose everything that is good about this country. I served in the military to protect our core values from foreign aggression. But, I can't protect the country from people like you who root for its demise.

I hope you grow up, acquire some wisdom, and learn to exercise some humility. It would benefit not only you, but the country as well. Be well.

James Quinn's avatar

“He likely meant”. He could as easily have meant just what I suggested he meant.

In any case suggesting that a man who advocated for a country flooded with guns may not have understand the irony of his death by gun violence is not ‘gloating’.

I never either advocated or justified political violence. Do not project your biases on me.

I too served in the military, back when over 50,000 of my brothers-in-arms died in a hot wet hell neither we nor most of our country ever truly understood, prolonged by the misinformation and lies of a government who, even if begun with the best intentions sold us down the river. So I don’t need any lectures about militarily defending our core values. We haven’t truly done that since 1945. Rather we’ve wasted tens of thousands of young American lives in three different distant wars we didn’t really understand and in which we never should have involved ourselves..

I am not rooting for our nation’s demise. I’ve taught our history for over 40 years, I know what we are supposed to stand for, and I know when and where we’ve done so and when and where we have not.

I also know that the current President of the United States is attempting to bring about our demise as a Republic, and he’s only too happy to promote violence in pursuit of that end.

If you can factually dispute anything I’ve said her, either in my own words or in my statement of facts, please do so.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Sep 11, 2025
Comment removed
James Quinn's avatar

Try to explain it away as you will, but tying yourself in knots to do so isn’t going to ride.

Noah Otte's avatar

One of liberal democracy’s great gifts is the ability to speak one’s mind without fear of violence. But we are rapidly losing it. Yascha, this piece is tremendous and couldn’t have come at a more crucial moment! RIP Charlie Kirk (1993-2025) 🕯️May his memory be a blessing! I’m shaken by this tragedy. That this could happen in the United States of America isn’t surprising but is still nonetheless so, so tragic. We’ve got to reunify this country!

Lulu Manus's avatar

Violent rhetoric invites violence. It's karmic.

Art Eckstein's avatar

That violence was coming from the Left, not from Charile Kirk. Designate someone a "fascist threat to the Repubic" and someone's likely to take a shot at him.

James Quinn's avatar

Designating someone who is a fascist threat the to Republic as fascist threat to the Republic isn’t the problem.

I’m not suggesting that Charile Kirk was such, but as I noted below, his own words concerning the Second Amendment do seem to have come back to haunt him and his family. Nor does it help that the President of the United States has openly espoused violence as long as it is done on his behalf.

After all, political violence is a deep part of our DNA. We were born in violence, and we’ve been plagued by regular episodes of it ever since. But when our president espouses it, we have come to a whole new level.

Deborah's avatar

As has been said many times, guns don't kill people, people kill people. There are thousands of gun laws on the books and none of them have stopped illegal guns, or shooters who steal, lie or use other methods to obtain the guns they use. If they couldn't get a gun they would use a knife, bomb, or car. The killer on the train in Charlotte didn't have a gun. Gun control advocates never acknowledge the many times legal guns are used by citizens to protect themselves and others. Everyone must stop glorifying and excusing violence, and swiftly punish violent people, then maybe we will have less violence.

Quinn's avatar

I’m sorry, but that’s asinine. You are right in a perfectly literal sense that a gun lacks the ability to make any kind of decision an thus cannot choose to kill anyone. But to argue that is to argue in bad faith and I think you know it. A gun makes it easier by an order of magnitude to kill someone, especially at a distance. You could kill someone up close with a knife or a gun, but good luck at 50’ with that knife. And that, of course is the point. That’s why we don’t throw spears in wars anymore. Distance and killing power in one package. You can’t just reload your spear, right? You could argue bows are similar to a gun and in a sense you would be right, but the convenience favor of a firearm is leagues better than that of a bow and arrow. Can’t exactly put a short bow in a holster for concealed carry now, can we, Deborah?

The right to murder at a distance is not a right I think worth having in civilized society. You should be ashamed of yourself for providing cover for those who would murder children in schools, just like Charlie Kirk. And that is monstrous.

Shame on you.

James Quinn's avatar

Perhaps you should start with the President of the United States who openly advocates violence as long as it on his behalf.

The math is simple. The more guns there are, the more people will use them to solve whatever problem they think they have with somebody else.

Knives and cars and explosives are designed for use in many ways, but none were specifically designed only to destroy. Guns are. And we have managed to make a sacred artifact out of something that was designed wholly for that purpose.

Lulu Manus's avatar

It's Trump who is villianizing good people and dispatching masked thugs to terrorize them. Something must give. Charlie condoned this.

Julia M's avatar

Are you honestly suggesting that Charlie Kirk engaged in violent rhetoric? What do you even mean by that? That he incited violence? Such a disgusting comment. No one deserves to die in such a brutal manner just because you don't agree with him. There is a clear line between incitement and speaking the truth.

James Quinn's avatar

“it’s worth [the] cost of, unfortunately, some gun deaths every single year so that we can have the Second Amendment.” Charlie Kirk

As you sow, so shall you reap.

gnashy's avatar

Psychopathic leftism, you’d fit in with lenin just fine. People should walk the fuck away from you.

Quinn's avatar

He’s directly quoting Charlie Kirk, dude. One must assume Mr. Kirk would have to have agreed that his own death would be worth his precious right to own guns, right? Otherwise he’s a hypocrite.

James Quinn's avatar

As usual from the right, insults instead of facts. Trump would be proud of you.

C M's avatar

Kirk supported shooting immigrants. Nothing settles moral relativism easier for me than overt calls for violence.

FreneticFauna's avatar

You could say the same thing to anyone who opposes mass surveillance. After all, murders would likely go down with an AI-enabled camera on every street corner. Just imagine how many could be saved with a China-style surveillance state.

James Quinn's avatar

Mass surveillance doesn’t kill people.

Marlene Barbera's avatar

To seize on a man’s death as an occasion for mockery is not political speech, it is desecration. Whatever you think of Charlie Kirk’s stance, he was a human being murdered in cold blood. To celebrate it is to join hands with the murderer.

Kirk’s point about the Second Amendment was not a wish for bloodshed but an acknowledgment of the tragic cost that comes with any freedom. We say the same about free speech — it protects vile words as well as noble ones. His argument was about liberty, not murder.

“As you sow, so shall you reap” does not mean “you deserve to be killed.”

It means the moral order holds us accountable for our actions.

To wield Scripture as a sneer against the murdered is to corrupt its meaning and put yourself in peril of the very judgment you invoke.

Charlie Kirk did not ‘reap’ death by being outspoken. He reaped admiration, loyalty, and, yes, hatred. But the bullet that killed him was not sown by his words — it was sown by the killer’s malice.

Do not confuse the victim with the crime.

Mocking Charlie Kirk’s murder is not argument, it is desecration. His words about liberty acknowledged tragic costs — they did not invite his own execution. The only one who ‘reaps’ here is the killer, and the harvest is bloodguilt.

Kenneth Crook's avatar

What is this freedom to bear arms nonsense? No European country has this weird obsession with gun ownership and they also dont have regular gun deaths. Kirk thought a few deaths were worth it for this supposed freedom, but I can't even begin to understand it.

James Quinn's avatar

A lot of words to try to wriggle around what the man said. He condoned a certain level of gun violence in support of the Second Amendment. To point that out is not to celebrate anything. Yet, as I noted, the irony is inescapable.

Ken Hehir's avatar

Simply a horrific and asinine statement! He never condoned violence.

James Quinn's avatar

Then what shall we take from his statement? That gun deaths somehow aren’t violent?

Julia M's avatar

Wow, and I thought this kind of callousness was reserved for schmucks on X

James Quinn's avatar

It was Mr. Kirk’s statement that was callous. I was merely pointing out the irony.

David Cearley's avatar

Without the second amendment, we wouldn't have a first amendment. Just ask the citizens of the UK who no longer have gun nor free speech rights.

James Quinn's avatar

Oh please. There are lots of places where free speech exists without gun rights - the UK being one of them.

Quinn's avatar

Cite your sources. You’re just reciting bumper sticker-level platitudes otherwise. When specifically has that been the case?

C M's avatar

I think we can agree that political violence is abhorrent while still recognizing that Charlie Kirk engaged in politically violent rhetoric. Normally I would save this for another time, but it really does feel like we are crossing the Rubicon of sorts. Kirk's rhetorical style was frequently violent and apocalyptic - claiming that Democrats "stand for everything God hates" or his support of Christian Dominionism. This type of rhetoric, while not overtly violent, intersects with actual political violence and ideology. So it gets somewhat blurry how culpable he was in creating the climate we are in today, but I would definitely say he was a major influence. I wish that society could reflect on this and reduce the dangerous rhetoric, but it's obvious that it's only being amplified.

Julia M's avatar

How does this intersect with actual violence? Can you give an example, because it sounds like one of those sweeping statements that has no basis in fact. Claiming that Democrats "stand for everything God hates" is not violent AT ALL, you can disagree with it, but there is nothing violent in that statement overt or otherwise. He is not calling anyone to do anything. By politically violent, do you mean statement that you disagree with? I saw him talk about the positive attributes of Christianity, is that what you consider Christian Dominionism... I don't think it's blurry at all. You shouldn't be murdered in cold blood for speaking your mind.

C M's avatar

Well I think an obvious example is January 6th, and rioters who expressed an intent to restore a theocracy within the US. He also supported Gays being stoned to death ("God's perfect law when it comes to sexual matters") and immigrants getting shot at the border ("at what point do we use real force"). These cross the line from implicit to explicit calls to violence in my mind.

I consider Christian Dominionism as exactly what Kirk advocated for - violent theocratic authoritarianism. He never left much to interpretation, he was always explicit in his beliefs. Listen to some of his speeches and tell me how you interpret them.

https://www.mediamatters.org/charlie-kirk/charlie-kirk-calls-shooting-and-whipping-migrants-southern-border-if-you-enter-we-have

gnashy's avatar

Just as a data point - after the embers cool a bit on this specifically, I'll be on the lookout for a fair article or two that tries to deal with this question. It's not a theatre-oid of the culture war I know enough about yet to know if I agree with you or not.

Marlene Barbera's avatar

To equate fiery rhetoric with murder is itself a dangerous confusion. Words may sting, offend, or provoke argument — but they are not gunfire. Political speech, even harsh speech, belongs to democracy. Murder does not.

Saying that Democrats “stand for everything God hates” is strong language, yes — but it is moral judgment, not a call to arms. Christian preachers have spoken that way for centuries. If you call that “political violence,” then the prophets and apostles stand guilty too.

Your logic implies that Kirk helped “create the climate” that killed him. That is perilously close to blaming the victim — the oldest alibi of the persecutor. The only climate that produced his death was hatred, and the only one culpable is the killer.

Charlie Kirk did not die for “apocalyptic rhetoric.” He died because he stood in public, unarmed, and refused to be silent. That is courage. And to blur the distinction between rhetoric and murder is not reflection. It is excuse.

C M's avatar

I am not equating the two or justifying his assassination. You are correct that Christian preachers have spoken in similar ways, and their rhetoric has also inspired violence. Trump made a point to mention Scalise, Thompson, Kirk, and himself as examples of leftist violence - but he intentionally left out violence committed against Hortman and Pelosi. That was intentional. Can you help me identify contemporary leftist versions of the oath keepers, three percenters, or patriot front?

I am not trying to dotted line anything Charlie said to his assassination. Like you said, just because his language is morally repugnant doesn't mean he should be murdered. But he was part of a movement that has sought to divide people and inspire hatred towards people like myself - he contributed to an environment where people choose violence instead of words. He has explicitly supported the use of violence instead of words. Like I said before, I can find his murder abhorrent while still recognizing his contribution to the culture of hate and division that we have today.

David Cearley's avatar

You can't simply label thoughts or words you dislike as "political violence". Violence is what happened to Charlie yesterday

C M's avatar

I was simply stating that Kirk used violent rhetoric. It's all on record, anyone can listen. When you call on certain people to be shot like he has - that's violent rhetoric.

Kenneth Crook's avatar

He spoke in a non-violent manner, but the content of his words was anything but.

FreneticFauna's avatar

Using violent rhetoric probably does make you a target of violence, but that's not a very meaningful metric in my eyes. At the end of the day, there exists a clear line between violent rhetoric and violence. The victims at Charlie Hebdo brought violence upon themselves by "inflicting violence" upon the believers of a religion. Were they wrong to do so? Were their deaths karmic?

Art Eckstein's avatar

We are talking about persistent personal attacks on a specific person as a fascist threat. This murder is the physical extension of that specific rhetoric levied at Kirkz

I hope you can see the difference. Charlie Hebdo were mere satirists, but some pious followers of the Religion of Peace got “offended” and killed them.

FreneticFauna's avatar

I don't follow online discussion closely enough to know how how Mr. Kirk was spoken of by his opponents. I also don't know what sort of rhetoric he used, although it's also irrelevant to me. He could've been saying the most vile things 24/7 and I would still be horrified by his murder.

David Cearley's avatar

The whole, words are violence thing is just a technique to silence people who's opinions you don't like.

If you don't support free speech, you don't support democracy either. There are plenty of people in thr left who would be quite happy to have an authoritarian government go they could silence or punish any who dare disagree with their politics. That's an impulse mostly absent from the right.

Alistair P D Bain's avatar

No one is compelled to accept that invitation, even in a shithole country like America.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 10, 2025
Comment deleted
Annie's avatar

Charlie's defense of the 2nd amendment does not diminish his worth or impact as a person who defended constitutional rights.

Julia M's avatar

Such a morally simplistic, silly point. You can agree that a law should stay in place, acknowledge that there are trade offs and find the law on balance fair. That doesn't mean you agree that anyone should be able to take a gun and shoot them in cold blood for expressing their right to free speech in a respectful way. It's like acknowledging that cars can travel at certain speed on freeways, acknowledging that the trade off is that there will be traffic accidents, resulting in fatalities. It doesn't then mean that anyone has a right to drive their car at 100 miles through a crowded shopping mall. It certainly doesn't mean that logically there is "nothing to see hear". There is a particular vein of cruelty and callousness that can say that about someone who has just been murdered in public, leaving behind a widow and fatherless children...

FreneticFauna's avatar

But we're not talking about it because he was killed by a gun. We're talking about it because he was killed during a public political event. This would be just as big a story had he been stabbed to death during it. On the other hand, had he been mugged and killed while walking home at night with groceries, it would hardly have been a story at all. The only reason it might become more than a one-off report in that scenario is because Trump is currently playing up crime.

Warden Gulley's avatar

BIG balz was mugged while walking home at night. And that provoked Trump enough to send the military into Washington DC. EVERYTHING is now a story. STORY TRUMPS FACT.

FreneticFauna's avatar

Indeed, hence why I included that final line. Usually, a high-profile person being killed in a mugging wouldn't be a major multi-day story national, but these aren't normal times.

Art Eckstein's avatar

No, Kirk was a very major conservative spokesman, murdered at a political rally. He had millions of followers. This is not merely being gunned up by Trump. This is shades of 1968.

FreneticFauna's avatar

I agree, I'm not saying it is being ginned up. I'm saying that, in an alternate world where he were killed in a mugging-gone-wrong, it wouldn't have been a truly major story. I was using that as a contrast to reality. My point is that this is notable not for the weapon he was killed with, but where and when he was killed in the context of who he was.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Sep 11, 2025
Comment deleted
FreneticFauna's avatar

It would have, but not to this extent. Imagine instead that one day he was hanging out with friends and was tragically killed when one of them mishandled a gun. He'd surely get an article due to his prominence, but that'd be it. At most, perhaps some left-wing outfits would write an article pushing for gun restrictions or improved gun safety. Instead, we're seeing bipartisan concern about the greater implications of his killing. We're seeing this very post from Yascha. The gun isn't the story, it's the assassination itself. Same as it would've been had he been stabbed or blown up. That being said, your point about political assassinations in the US being conducted with guns 2/3 times is a fair one. Non-gun assassinations can happen (see the UK) and gun assassinations can occur in countries with strict restrictions (see Japan), but access to guns must make it easier for would-be-killers.

William Markham's avatar

This is out and away the best commentary on yesterday's atrocity that I have read. Free speech means nothing unless it means that each person can freely express his views on matters of public importance, even if others are deeply offended by them.

If others find a speaker's views to be ill-conceived, cynical, denigrating, or malevolent, their remedy is to explain why and to convince others of their own preferred views.

Punishing or harming a speaker for his views is always a direct affront to our right of free speech, which for good reason is enshrined in the very first article of our Bill of Rights. Societies that repress free speech tend to founder over time, and those that respect it tend to flourish. That is not a coincidence. Free speech not only allows us, but obliges us to reconsider our views and to have them tested by the reason, logic, and experience of others.

Yesterday was a very sorry and horrifying day for the country. Full stop.

Guy's avatar

You’ve misspoken here:

Indeed, some Democrats already seem to have fallen into that trap, objecting to a Republican motion for the House of Representatives to observe a moment of silence in Kirk’s honor.

Actually, after 30 seconds of silence Bobert called for a spoken prayer to follow it. Dems objected to that.

Peter Brooks's avatar

CORRECTION to your post please: The Democrats did not object to the moment of silence. The entire chamber was silent for this time, ended when Johnson gavelled back to normal business. Republican Lauren Boebert, claiming that silent prayer is ineffective, asked for a spoken prayer. At this point, Democrats objected as it is generally unprecedented in these contexts. A shouting match followed, including Republicans accusing the Democrats for bearing responsibility of Kirk’s murder.

Warden Gulley's avatar

Was Charlie Kirk the collateral damage of "gun deaths" as he described in April 2023, or was he the victim of "gun violence" as the progressives proclaim. Gun deaths and Gun violence are euphemisms used by segments of a society that are engaged in an alternate reality of blamelessness. It's not my fault, I've been framed. Or, the other guy did it. Our society will collapse and implode unless it ascends beyond this blameless moral relativism.

Justapunk74's avatar

Well said. At some point we need to say enough...wrong is wrong, no matter what "side" it comes from

Warden Gulley's avatar

I agree. Both extremes are comprised of the indoctrinated and have completely abandoned rationality. Each operates with a kernel of truth, but morphs and spins that into something that can deliver political power. This is not about solving problems or addressing issues. It is about an alternate reality seeking raw political power.

Jorg Donde's avatar

Note, though: it does not seem that a moment of silence was ignored. The chamber did that, but then Boebert demanded a *spoken* prayer, which led to the disruption.

m a medford's avatar

In a November 2023 issue of The Atlantic, McKay Coppins wrote a sentence that keeps haunting me: "How long can a democracy last when its elected leaders live in fear of physical violence from their constituents?"

He wrote that in response to something Mitt Romney said to him as part of his article, and it was specifically talking about elected politicians. But I'm worried we're on a quick trajectory of being able to say that about anyone who expresses a political view at all. Change the original wording to, "How long can a democracy last when its citizens live in fear of physical violence from their fellow citizens because they've expressed their political views?" Two years ago (when the article was written) it was elected leaders. Yesterday it was an activist and media personality. How soon until it's regular to hear of neighbors shooting neighbors over their political views?